the most wonderful time to


With our delicious holiday gifts
Here we are as in olden days

Discover ways
to reconnect

Find the gifts that bring people together
Keep it simple this year

Ship to multiple addresses

Take care of everyone in one place
Love is in the air

Share something sweet

Thoughtful, local, and delicious
Everything made with

Real & simple ingredients

Timeless classics that comfort the soul

We've put together a special line of Nettie's favorites so that you can send a piece of home to those far away.

Our favorite
Holiday Gift Tower
Packed full of our best selling holiday treats and available in three different sizes, this makes the perfect gift for anyone on your list!
Order now
Nettie's Classic
Holiday Cookie Gift Box
A combination of seasonal favorites and perennial best sellers make this beautiful gift box a true crowd pleaser
Order Now
Classic Bakery Tower
Just what you're looking for
It's fresh. It's sweet. It's special. It's unique. Just like the person you're sending it to. This tower of our most popular items shows them just how much you care.
Order Now

A gathering place

More than just a Bakery

We believe that a bakery should be a place where a community can come together. We've gone all out to make that happen.

Read More!

Sip some tea in

A Quiet Corner

We couldn't just watch an old barn go to waste. So, as we often do, we got busy preserving something nostalgic. You'll love the way it turned out.

Our Story

We're a tad bit nostalgic

Our story is one of working, dreaming, learning, and doing. With every step, we've preserved a bit of history, whether in our old fashioned recipes, or the restored woodwork in our store.

Read More!

Our retail store

366 Railroad Avenue, Center Moriches, NY 11934

Fri-Sun: 7AM-4PM

Get directions